By Megan Sanders

9 October 2018

The recent case of Kiraig Pty Ltd as trustee for Jovette Trust & Anor v Rent the Roo Pty LTd & Anor [2017] FFCA 1493 (30 June 2017) (Kiraig) has cast doubt as to the enforceability of a commonly used form of renewal clause.

Kiraig concerned a master franchisee. Its rights to renew for a further term were typical in the franchising space. They required that it must enter into a new master franchise agreement in the form of the Franchisor’s then current master franchise agreement, which would not contain terms “substantially different” to the existing agreement.

However, the Court held that the clause was void for uncertainty and that “what purported to be an option which upon exercise caused a new contract to come into existence, was, in reality, only an agreement to agree…”.

Key factors for finding the clause void included:

  1. Lack of satisfactory evidence that the documentation issued by the Franchisor represented its then current master franchise agreement;
  2. Lack of an “agreed mechanism to arbitrate on any differences of view” over what constituted
    substantially different terms; and
  3. The fact that the clause required that the new agreement must not be on substantially different terms to both the “essential terms” of the agreement “as well as other, less important, provisions which could be worked out if an agreement existed because essential terms were agreed…”

The decision ultimately left the master franchisee with no business to sell and serves as a timely reminder of the need for careful drafting of renewal provisions and of the importance of obtaining quality legal advice prior to entering into any Franchise Agreement.

 

If you require advice surrounding Franchising Law, please do not hesitate to contact Megan Sanders or a member of our Commercial team.

 

The full case transcript can be found here: Kiraig Pty Ltd as trustee for Jovette Trust & Anor v Rent the Roo Pty LTd & Anor [2017] FFCA 1493

Related Articles

View All
Commercial Law / Commercial Contracts & Agreements

Commercial Tenancy Relief Scheme Regulations 2021

In the technology space, this time of year is often linked with the anticipated release of the new models of Apple...
Read More
Commercial Law

Directors beware – Corporations Act changes tighten the rules for exiting Directors.

Recent changes to the Corporations Act can prevent a director from exiting and alter the effective date of resignations...
Read More
Leasing & Lease Disputes / Real Estate Agents / Commercial Law

COVID-19 – Commercial Tenancy Relief Scheme to be extended (again)

The CTRS was initially expected to end on 29 September 2020 under the COVID-19 Omnibus (Emergency Measures)(Commercial...
Read More
Commercial Law

Verification of online customers: Is your business complying with the new AML/KYC laws?

The changes apply to any business receiving funds from customers that are not already known to them This includes...
Read More
Retail Clients & Chains / Commercial Law

A win for the Tigers on the field and in the Court of Appeal

On 16 October 2020 the Court of Appeal confirmed that a ‘retail premises lease’ will remain subject to the Retail...
Read More
Commercial Law / Leasing & Lease Disputes

COVID-19 Lease Variations- How to document it properly

We have written several blogs about commercial leases and licences and the impact COVID-19 has had on them and what the...
Read More
Commercial Law / Commercial Contracts & Agreements / Corporate Advisory and M&A

Announcing our Promotions

Rob joined us in 2017 and immediately impressed us with his litigation skills and incredible work ethic It’s no...
Read More
Commercial Contracts & Agreements / Commercial Law

When contracts end: The perils of miscommunication and misunderstanding

From a practical perspective, the most critical thing for any party to a contract to appreciate is the importance of...
Read More
Commercial Law / Mortgages, Loans & Finance / Mezzanine Finance

Private lending: the red flags

Today, it may appear amicable and you do not foresee anything going wrong after the money is advanced Surely, it’s...
Read More
Commercial Law / Commercial Contracts & Agreements / Corporate Advisory and M&A

Negotiating Indemnities: Some Practical Tips

An appropriate indemnity can provide a valuable mechanism for risk allocation between parties to commercial dealings...
Read More
Commercial Law / Property & Development / Developments

TLFC Law Triple Finalists in the Lawyers Weekly Australian Law Awards 2019

Celebrating its 19th year, the Australian Law Awards, in partnership with UNSW Law, is the pinnacle of award programs...
Read More
Commercial Law / Franchising & Licensing / Real Estate Agents

Thinking of buying or selling a Rent Roll?

However, rent rolls are regulated by the Estate Agent’s Act and it is important that the contract to buy or sell the...
Read More