By Bianca Mazzarella

4 June 2021

Everyone secretly loves observing chaos (as long as they are not in it).  That’s why people slow down to look at car accidents.

Up until recently, businesses have relied upon ‘gig’ workers being able to be classified as independent contractors due to working for a number of platforms at the same time and have avoided paying employee related entitlements.


The recent Deliveroo decision (see below) means businesses should proceed with caution when assessing whether or not to engage independent contractors.

Recent decision for all businesses to be aware of- Franco v Deliveroo Australia Pty Ltd [2021] FWC 2818 (‘Deliveroo’)


This recent decision has revealed division in the Fair Work Commission as it contradicts a 2020 full bench decision which found that Ubereats drivers are not employees.


How the Deliveroo decision impacts businesses?

Gig workers have been at the centre of the employee vs contractor debate for some time now.


Business owners have a history of classifying workers as contractors to avoid paying employee entitlements and protection under unfair dismissal legislation.


Although, Deliveroo will appeal this decision it is prudent for all companies who employ ‘gig’ workers to look at the ‘complete picture’ in determining whether or not there is an employment or a true independent contractor relationship.


Factors to consider when assessing whether or not a ‘gig’ worker is an employee or independent contractor

  1. Is the ‘gig’ worker carrying on a trade or business of their own/have their own ABN?
  2. Is it the ‘gig’ workers primary source of income?
  3. Who has control over when and how the work is performed?
  4. Does the worker have to wear a uniform?
  5. Does the business measure or monitor the worker’s performance?
  6. Can the worker subcontract work?


These are just some of the many factors an employer, director or business owner should consider when determining whether or not there is an employment or contractor relationship.


Hefty penalties apply to businesses who incorrectly classify employees as contractors – $13,320 for individuals and $66,600 for corporations per contravention.


There is no doubt that the law is unclear and has struggled to evolve as career opportunities move away from more traditional employment.


This ambiguity will inevitably be dealt with by the High Court but in the meantime please do not hesitate to contact our employment team if your business is uncertain as to whether your workers or suppliers are contractors or casual employees.

Related Articles

View All
Employment Law

‘R E S P E C T’- Part 2 – find out what it means…..for women

As foreshadowed in our previous article, the Federal Government has succumbed to public pressure and taken much needed...
Read More
Employment Law

Superannuation Increase – Who wears the cost?

From 1 July 2021, a superannuation (super) increase from 95% to 10% of employee’s ordinary time earnings will occur...
Read More
Employment Law

‘R E S P E C T’- find out what it means…..for employers

On 8 April 2021 the government publicly endorsed recommendations of the Respect@Work Report, commissioned by the Sex...
Read More
Employment Law

Snap lock down without JobKeeper, what happens now?

Businesses are no longer able to rely upon JobKeeper to keep their businesses and staff afloat and are left wondering...
Read More
Employment Law

Does anyone other than HR know about your workplace policies?

  What are policies and why does my business need them A workplace policy outlines a company or organisation’s...
Read More
Employment Law

When can I direct an employee to get the COVID-19 jab and what can I do if they refuse?

FWO further guidance The FWO has now provided further guidance in relation to when it is lawful and reasonable for an...
Read More
Employment Law

Can an employer force an employee to get the COVID-19 jab?

This question is topical given recent discussions around the roll out of the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine in Australia and...
Read More
Employment Law / Small to Medium Enterprises

Full Federal Court allows double dipping for casual employees

Justice Bromberg and the Full Federal Court of Australia have once again delivered bad news for employers  In certain...
Read More
Employment Law / Small to Medium Enterprises / Start-ups & Emerging Enterprises

Fair Work Commission amends 99 Awards during COVID-19 Pandemic

On Wednesday, 8 April 2020, as a result of the COVID-19 Pandemic, a six (6) member Fair Work Commission full bench,...
Read More
Employment Law

New industrial manslaughter laws are no laughing matter for employers

What are the laws The new laws will be applicable to all employers, self-employed individuals and officers of a company...
Read More
Employment Law / Commercial Law / Litigation & Dispute Resolution

What employers need to know when letting someone go

A staff member may need to be let go because the business can no longer afford them, or perhaps they are just not...
Read More