VCAT Declares Owners Corporation Rule Prohibiting Pets Being Kept in Private Lots Invalid & Unenforceable
The Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT) has recently applied the Supreme Court of Victoria’s leading judgment on the legal principles about determining the legal validity of registered Owners Corporation Rules regarding prohibiting pets, namely:
“(a) What was the statutory purpose of the relevant provisions in the legislation?
(b) What is the character of special rule?
(c) Is there a sufficiently direct and substantial connection between the statutory purpose and the likely operation of the rule?”
The case involved an Owners Corporation that had two registered Owners Corporation Rules prohibiting pets on common property and private lots. The rules said:
“Pets are not allowed on common property”
“Pets are not allowed in units”
VCAT found that the rules were invalid because the Owners Corporation did not have the power to make the rules prohibiting pets because they unfairly discriminated against animal owners in the context of that particular subdivision.
Case Reference: Owners Corporation SP24474 v Watkins (Owners Corporations) [2016] VCAT 1312 (11 August 2016)
Any further questions, please contact a member of our Owners Corporation team.
Related Articles
View AllInvestigations into building wide issues like leaks from flexi hoses
By Phillip Leaman
26 July 2024
If there’s a leak from upstairs, does the owners corporation get involved?
By Phillip Leaman
26 July 2024
Occupancy permits – the ticking clock in defective building work
Telecommunication Leases and Owners Corporations
By Phillip Leaman
8 November 2022
Courtyards and car spaces – Do you have the legal right to use them?
By Phillip Leaman
26 October 2022
Owners Corporations- Do you have adequate rules?
By Phillip Leaman
25 October 2022
Know your plan of subdivision- Owners corporations who owns what?
By Phillip Leaman
30 September 2022
Brief summary of the new Owners Corporations ACT
By Phillip Leaman
11 March 2022
Defective domestic building works but no written major domestic building contract – Do you still have an obligation to pay the builder?
By Phillip Leaman
25 June 2021
Easements and Owners Corporations
By Phillip Leaman
4 June 2021
Adverse possession and Owners Corporations
By Phillip Leaman
1 June 2021
Common Property and repairs by lot owners
By Phillip Leaman
26 May 2021