Owners Corporation Legal Case Update.

The Owners Corporation Act 2006 (VIC) (‘OC Act’) provides that an Owners Corporation must take out reinstatement and replacement insurance for all buildings on the common property. The definition of building in the OC Act has been expanded to include “any improvements and fixtures forming part of the building”. This has led to some confusion regarding the extent of an Owners Corporation’s insurance obligations and thus the duty of the managing agent.

However, a recent case in VCAT has helped define the scope of these obligations, as a lot owner was successful in bringing an action against the managing agent for failing to insure the lot’s fixtures. The proceedings commenced as the compressor of an air-conditioning unit attached to the relevant lot, which was not covered by the Owners Corporation’s insurance policy, broke down. The lot owner was successful in arguing that the compressor was a fixture of the property as it was present when the lot was purchased and was not intended to be kept by the lot owner upon sale of the property. Furthermore, it was irrelevant that the compressor could be detached because the detachment would be a long and arduous procedure. Therefore, it was decided the compressor and the air-conditioning unit should have been covered by insurance.

This finding raised questions as to whether the managing agent breached its duty to exercise due care and diligence in the performance of its functions. There was evidence to suggest the manager knew the Owners Corporation did not have mechanical breakdown insurance and did not urgently obtain a quote or raise the issue with the Owners Corporation at the next Annual General Meeting. The tribunal held that a reasonable manager, with similar knowledge and experience as the current manager, should have addressed these issues urgently. Accordingly the manager was considered to have breached its obligation to exercise due care and diligence.

Case Reference: M.R.O Nominees Pty Ltd v Network Pacific Real Estate Pty Ltd (Owners Corporations) [2013] VCAT 1492.

 

Any further questions, please contact a member of our Owners Corporation team.

Related Articles

View All
Construction / Owners Corporations / Planning

Occupancy permits – the ticking clock in defective building work

Where multiple occupancy permits are issued in relation to a building permit, which permit is the operative permit for...
Read More
Owners Corporations / Owners Corporations & Strata

Telecommunication Leases and Owners Corporations

Owners Corporations may lease or licence common property to lot owners (or other third parties) in accordance with...
Read More
Owners Corporations / Owners Corporations & Strata

Courtyards and car spaces – Do you have the legal right to use them?

Owners Corporations may lease or licence common property to lot owners (or other third parties) in accordance with...
Read More
Owners Corporations / Owners Corporations & Strata

Owners Corporations- Do you have adequate rules?

Section 138 of the Owners Corporations Act gives the power to the Owners Corporation to make rules by special...
Read More
Owners Corporations / Owners Corporations & Strata

Know your plan of subdivision- Owners corporations who owns what?

Boundaries can be median where half the structure is owned by the Owners Corporation or a private lot owner and the...
Read More
Owners Corporations / Owners Corporations & Strata

Brief summary of the new Owners Corporations ACT

Expert Owners Corporations lawyers, Tisher Liner FC Law, explained the changes to the Owners Corporations Act 2006 in a...
Read More
Owners Corporations / Owners Corporations & Strata

Defective domestic building works but no written major domestic building contract – Do you still have an obligation to pay the builder?

To always ensure you have an enforceable major domestic building contract for domestic building works over the value of...
Read More
Owners Corporations / Owners Corporations & Strata

Easements and Owners Corporations

Easements can be tricky for landowners let alone for Owners Corporations There are a number of easements that can...
Read More
Owners Corporations / Owners Corporations & Strata

Adverse possession and Owners Corporations

Whilst lot owners are unable to make a claim for adverse possession in respect to common property claims can still be...
Read More
Owners Corporations / Owners Corporations & Strata

Common Property and repairs by lot owners

Our earlier blog gave a summary of the changes to the Owners Corporations Act 2006 which commence on 1 December 2021 as...
Read More
Owners Corporations / Owners Corporations & Strata

Insurance

Our earlier blog gave a summary of the changes to the Owners Corporations Act 2006 which commence on 1 December 2021 as...
Read More
Owners Corporations / Owners Corporations & Strata

Voting and Quorums

Our earlier blog gave a summary of the changes to the Owners Corporations Act 2006 which commence on 1 December 2021 as...
Read More