By Phillip Leaman

12 February 2018

An alarming case in the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal has set an uncomfortable precedent for developers seeking planning permits for subdivisions.

In an early Christmas present from the Tribunal on 22 December 2017, the Tribunal in Tarneit Projects Pty Ltd v Wyndham City Council upheld planning permit conditions which required the developer to provide land for road widening at no cost to the Council.

The case involves a developer Tarneit Projects Pty Ltd who was seeking planning permission to allow a 306 lot subdivision over seven stages in Tarneit. The Wyndham City Council imposed a permit condition that the developer had to vest in the name of the Council at no cost a 3.9 metre wide strip of land for future road widening works. The condition arises from a mandatory condition that was required to be included by the provisions of the Urban Growth Zone and the relevant Precinct Structure Plan (Riverdale PSP).

What was found?

The Tribunal has no discretion to delete or amend a mandatory provision of the planning scheme and is bound to apply it. The developer argued that the condition was tantamount to compulsory acquisition without the benefit of compensation under the Land Acquisition and Compensation Act and that the condition was unjust.

The Council has the power to require ‘works, services or facilities’ that a responsible authority considers necessary to be provided by a permit applicant or paid for wholly by the applicant.

Lessons for developers

When purchasing or developing land, make sure regard is had to all conditions in the planning scheme and any precinct structure plans. If there is to be a planning scheme amendment introduced over land you currently own, consider whether an objection to the amendment should be made. Once a mandatory provision is set, you will be bound to follow it and any costs need to be considered as part of the costs of development.


For expert advice on planning and development matters contact Phillip Leaman or one of the Property Law team.

Related Articles

View All
Construction / Owners Corporations / Planning

Occupancy permits – the ticking clock in defective building work

Where multiple occupancy permits are issued in relation to a building permit, which permit is the operative permit for...
Read More
Property & Development / Planning

The 1, 2, 3 of Property Law Reminders for NY2023

In so reflecting, reflecting on one’s property matters (current or proposed for the future) is also a worthwhile...
Read More
Planning / Property & Development / Construction

Section 9AC of the Sale of Land Act – What does ‘materially affect’ mean?

Throughout the registration period, a Plan of Subdivision may undergo many amendments from the proposed Plan which was...
Read More
Adverse Possession / Planning

Paving the way to land ownership: How to claim adverse possession without fences

There are three main requirements for an adverse possession claim which are as follows: Actual Possession – You will...
Read More
Commercial Contracts & Agreements / Leasing & Lease Disputes / Property & Development

Could you Be Contaminated?

Whether you are the purchaser of land, the seller, a landlord, a tenant, a developer or a lender, there are obligations...
Read More
Compulsory Acquisition / Planning

Loss of Properties under North East Link Imminent

The current North East Link project intends to have the following effect on businesses and landowners according to the...
Read More
Owners Corporations / Owners Corporations & Strata / Planning

Cladding Rectification Agreements: what you need to know about getting a loan to replace flammable cladding

The new legislation, which came into effect of 30 October 2018, will enable local councils to enter into a cladding...
Read More
Technology and Start Ups / Adverse Possession / Commercial Law

TLFC – Award Finalist for Law Firm of the Year (Medium Category)

Tisher Liner FC are proud to be nominated as an award finalist in the 14th annual Victorian Legal Awards Medium Law...
Read More
Adverse Possession / Planning / Covenants & Easements

Roads – What are they and how do you get rid of them

What are Roads Roads can include streets, rights of way, passages, bridges, footpaths, kerbing and public highways...
Read More
Planning / Developments

Planning Minister puts a limit on CBD apartment tower heights for now

The Controls have been introduced pending the larger review called the Central City Built Form Review which is being...
Read More
Planning / Developments

New Victorian Planning Zones to change the development landscape.

Residential Zones – So what has changed The existing Residential 1 Zone, Residential 2 Zone and Residential 3 Zone...
Read More