By Phillip Leaman

6 May 2013

Section 61 of the Retail Leases Act 2003 deals with when a landlord can withhold consent of a proposed transfer of lease by the tenant.

We acted for the successful landlord party in a Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal decision just released in which the landlord refused consent to an assignment of lease on the basis that the proposed tenant lacked sufficient business experience and financial resources. The case involved a sushi and noodle bar which was licenced.

The proposed tenant had no experience in the restaurant business or in any business but relied on a un-official business partner who did have some limited business experience to manage the business. The landlord withheld consent and the tenant issued proceedings at VCAT seeking an order that the transfer be permitted.

VCAT confirmed that the landlord had not been unreasonable in withholding consent and dismissed the tenant’s application. VCAT stated that whilst a tenant might be able to meet the obligations of operating such a café without extensive experience, a tenant without any experience in running a food business may not be able to meet the obligations under the lease. Further, VCAT determined that in order for a landlord to be able to properly assess a tenant’s financial position, the prospective tenant must provide sufficient and substantiated documents to show the prospective tenant’s financial resources.

Lessons to be learned:

Tenants –Treat the request to the landlord for assignment of the lease seriously and not as a mere formality. Provide comprehensive and detailed information on the proposed tenant’s business experience and financial resources.

Landlords –Assess the information provided by the proposed assignee and withhold consent if necessary (you are deemed to consent if you do not withhold consent formally within 28 days of a request).

Related Articles

View All
Leasing & Lease Disputes / Litigation & Dispute Resolution

We Won a Billboard!

Tisher Liner FC Law has won a brilliant new billboard, owing to achieving recent success for our client in the County...
Read More
Commercial Contracts & Agreements / Leasing & Lease Disputes / Property & Development

Exercising Options

If a lease is a retail lease, the provisions of the Retail Leases Act (Vic) (2003) will govern the exercise of option...
Read More
Leasing & Lease Disputes / Real Estate Agents / Small to Medium Enterprises

Is your retail tenant continuously in breach of your retail lease but still wants to renew the lease for another term?

A tenant can be in breach of a lease in a multitude of ways depending on each lease, be it late rent and outgoings...
Read More
Adverse Possession / Commercial Law / Family Law

2024 Best Lawyers list out now

Tisher Liner FC Law are proud to announce that this year three of our Principals have been selected by their peers for...
Read More
Property & Development / Leasing & Lease Disputes / Real Estate Agents

CTRS protections has ended. What do you do now when a tenant defaults?

What can landlords do if a tenant breaches the lease If a tenant is in breach of a lease, the landlord may charge...
Read More
Commercial Contracts & Agreements / Commercial Law / Leasing & Lease Disputes

The 2022 Commercial Tenancy Relief Scheme Regulations are now in effect

The 2022 Regulations were foreshadowed in a press release issued by the Victorian Government on 15 January 2022 Click...
Read More
Leasing & Lease Disputes / Property & Development / Real Estate Agents

COVID-19 and the new Commercial Tenancy Relief Scheme

A global pandemic, an economy forced into hibernation, and repeated, extended, and somewhat unpredictable lockdowns…...
Read More
Property & Development / Leasing & Lease Disputes / Owners Corporations & Strata

Head leases and the Retail Leases Act 2003

In the recent case of Izett St Pty Ltd v Applgold Pty Ltd (Building and Property) [2021] VCAT 174 (3 March 2021, Senior...
Read More
Leasing & Lease Disputes / Real Estate Agents / Retail Clients & Chains

Need extra time on your retail lease? This may help you.

We have observed that tenants are not just being put under financial distress to pay the rent because of the government...
Read More
Leasing & Lease Disputes / Real Estate Agents / Commercial Law

COVID-19 – Commercial Tenancy Relief Scheme to be extended (again)

The CTRS was initially expected to end on 29 September 2020 under the COVID-19 Omnibus (Emergency Measures)(Commercial...
Read More
Franchising & Licensing / Leasing & Lease Disputes / Property & Development

Amendments to the Commercial Tenancy Relief Scheme

In this blog, we have referred to the original regulations[1] as the “Principal Regulations” and the amending...
Read More
Leasing & Lease Disputes / Property & Development / Real Estate Agents

COVID-19 and the New Changes to Leasing

Additional measures are being introduced in relation to commercial tenancies, including the following: An extension to...
Read More