By Simon Abraham

12 January 2015

In March 2014, the Harvard Business Review published an article entitled "Hire Slow, Fire Fast".

The essence of the article is that successful businesses should be ‘absurdly selective’ in who they hire. When an employee is not working out, successful businesses don’t allow the problem to fester but also manage to treat the employee with dignity.

Sadly, too often in Australia it is the other way around. Unsuitable employees are often engaged hastily due to time pressures whilst employees that are not performing are left in place where they consume a disproportionate amount of management time and morale is inevitably damaged. The usual reason given by employers for such inaction is fear of being involved in unfair dismissal proceedings.

It isn’t only small businesses that fall into this trap. In mid-2014, Myer hired Andrew Flanagan as group general manager for strategic and business development which came with a $ 400,000 salary. Mr Flanagan’s CV stated that he had worked for a Spanish fashion company, Inditex Group, that owns the global ‘fast fashion’ chain Zara. His CV and references were falsified. He had previously used a false CV to work at other businesses. Myer fired him on his first day in the job after his fraud was belatedly uncovered.

Employers should learn from Myer’s mistakes and take the following steps where possible:

  • Always carry out a police check of prospective employees who are to be engaged in a position of trust. We can refer you to external companies that carry out such searches for a modest sum. We can also put an employment contract in place that gives employers the right to carry out such searches as a pre-condition of employment.
  • Reference checks should be carefully carried out. Don’t rely upon a recruitment company alone. They may well be getting scammed as well. We recommend undertaking your own separate reference checks.
  • Carry out a Google search of the prospective employee. In Mr Flanagan’s case, he had no LinkedIn account or any other internet record of his alleged ‘employment’ history.
  • For the most senior roles, we can carry out a search of the National Personal Insolvency Index (bankruptcy) and a number of Courts also have online search facilities.

When firing an employee it is important that steps are taken to minimise an unfair dismissal claim and to protect the intellectual property and goodwill of the business. In most cases, it is appropriate to have the employee leave immediately and pay them their notice in lieu. However, you must ensure that the employment agreement and the Fair Work Act are complied with in all respects.


For more information please contact Simon Abraham or a member of our Employment Law Team.

Related Articles

View All
Employment Law / Litigation & Dispute Resolution / Intellectual Property

Dude, Where’s my Business? High Court Delivers Warning to Employees and Competitors who engage in Dishonest Conduct to Get Ahead in the Game

The case of Ancient Foresters in Victoria Friendly Society Limited v Lifeplan Australia Friendly Society Limited [2018]...
Read More
Employment Law / Litigation & Dispute Resolution / Construction

Does it Really Matter What You Call Your Employees? The Difference Between a Permanent and a Casual Employee.

The Federal Court found the casual employee worked a regular and continuous pattern of work for more than two years,...
Read More
Business Law / Construction / Employment Law

September 2018 Newsletter

September 2018 Newsletter See the full newsletter here Welcome TLFC Law are pleased to welcome Min Seetoh to the...
Read More
Business Law / Employment Law / Real Estate Agents

Are you complying with the Real Estate Industry Award? Don’t get caught out!

Changes to the Real Estate Industry Award 2010 Important changes to the Award include: Classification of employees and...
Read More
Australia-Israel Legal Advice / Charities & Not-for-Profit / Technology and Start Ups

TLFC – Award Finalist for Law Firm of the Year (Medium Category)

Tisher Liner FC are proud to be nominated as an award finalist in the 14th annual Victorian Legal Awards Medium Law...
Read More
Employment Law

First they came for the accountants…

With several popular restaurants recently making headlines for allegedly underpaying employees, it is a good time for...
Read More
Employment Law

Casual to Permanent Swap

The Fair Work Commission (Commission) will introduce a “ casual conversion ” clause into modern awards following a...
Read More
Employment Law

How discretionary are “Discretionary Employee Payments”?

These policies (or contacts of employment themselves) may incorporate a statement to the effect that these are ex...
Read More
Employment Law

Why (most) Post-Employment Restraints are Illegal

What is the relevance of this to post employment restraints Post employment restraints, without proper limitations,...
Read More
Business Law / Employment Law

Employee Departures | How to Protect your Business

A large part of the parameters of these are already set down in whatever employment contract your employee has been...
Read More
Employment Law / Business Law

The Unsigned Employment Contract | Binding Agreement or Meaningless Piece of Paper?

Employers prepare such documents and present them to prospective employees at the commencement of the employment...
Read More
Employment Law

When “Super” may not be so Super

In either case, in the event of a Member’s death, the amount which has accumulated, known as the Death Benefit, may...
Read More